1. Doublemint — $1.40
I cannot get enough of Doublemint’s mellow yet cooling spearmint—it is the kind of gum that feels instantly refreshing without hitting you over the head with sweetness. The soft, easy
chew keeps that classic freshness consistent from start to finish. Unlike gums that hang around with sickening sweetness long after their mint flavor fades, Doublemint knows when to bow out gracefully. At a shockingly low price for a standard 15-stick pack, it is an easy, everyday grab. No gimmicks, no fuss—just reliably satisfying mint. Honestly, it is the kind of gum that makes you wonder why you ever tried anything else.
2. Extra Spearmint — $1.72
Extra Spearmint has been my go-to gum for years, and honestly, I will never stop grabbing it. The spearmint flavor is perfectly balanced—subtle enough to stay in the background but minty enough to keep you feeling fresh and put-together. The texture is smooth, and while the flavor does not last as long as some gums, it is far more enjoyable and satisfying than others, making longevity less of a concern. At a great price for 15 sticks, it is an easy, everyday staple. I always feel like I am making the safe, smart choice with this one. Reliable, refreshing, and exactly what I want from a classic spearmint.
3. Orbit — $2.20
Orbit comes at you with a sharp, almost tart mint blast that grabs your attention immediately. At first, I thought it might be a little too much, but it quickly mellowed into a smooth, crisp mint that was easy to enjoy. The flavor lasts close to an hour, which is impressive, but even with its longevity, it is not the most delightful mint experience, so that extra time does not feel like a huge advantage. Every so often, the tang pops back out in waves, keeping things interesting. With the classic 14-stick pack at a fair price, it is easy to see why so many people love it. Not my personal favorite, but I get why Orbit is well-known.
4. 5 Gum — $2.79
Right from the first chew, 5 Gum hits with a bold, icy blast that wakes you up instantly. I was not too sure about the intensity at the start, and the texture was a bit too soft for my taste, both of which bring it down for me. Fortunately for this pick, its flavor stuck around longer than I expected and calmed down to a pleasant freshness after that initial punch, but it is slightly pricey and not always easy to find in stores. I had not seen this gum around much before, so discovering it felt like finding a little hidden gem. It is fun, edgy, and a little exciting compared to the classics, but those downsides explain why it is not higher on the list. To be fair, I might purchase this gum again if I am craving something bold, but I would think the decision over.
5. Trident Vibes — $4.37
Trident Vibes are a flavor bomb from the first bite—a spearmint-sweet mix that lingers in the best way. The cubes have a springy, satisfying chew, but the oversized plastic container is clunky and inconvenient to carry. At a higher price for 40 cubes, it feels more like a treat than an everyday gum. While the flavor lasts, it is not as refined as gums higher on this list, such as Doublemint or Extra Spearmint, so it is more of a playful option than a go-to. Still, I somewhat enjoy its bold, unconventional vibe. This is the gum I would grab if I wanted something a little extra, but it has enough drawbacks to keep it from ranking higher.
6. Ice Breakers Ice Cubes — $4.70
Ice Breakers products are all about novelty, and I will admit that the first sweet, crunchy bite is oddly satisfying. But the mint disappears in minutes, leaving mostly candy-like sweetness
behind, one that is vaguely reminiscent of watermelon—definitely not what I am looking for in a mint gum. The soft texture is fine, but the bulky, rattling container makes it frustrating to carry around. With 40 cubes at the highest price on this list, it does not offer much bang for your buck. Ice Breakers are fun for a quick chew, sure, but they cannot compete with gums that actually refresh and last. Honestly, I could only picture someone reaching for this one if they wanted something different.